|Episode #||Season 10, Episode 1|
|First aired||October 7, 2014|
|Directed by||Robert Singer|
|Written by||Jeremy Carver|
|Outline||As Dean is living it up as a demon with Crowley, Sam frantically searches for his missing brother. Meanwhile, Castiel is still dealing with his waning grace when Hannah arrives, and seeks his aide in finding two rogue angels still on Earth.|
|Timeline||Six weeks after 9.23 Do You Believe in Miracles?|
|Location(s)|| Lebanon, Kansas|
Amherst Junction, Wisconsin
Beulah, North Dakota
|« Previous Episode | Next Episode »|
Back at the Bunker, Sam keeps researching – looking for signs of demonic activity by tracking weather events, cattle deaths, and crop failures, and by calling other hunters. He wanders into Dean's bedroom and looks at the only clue he has, a note left presumably by Dean that reads, "Sammy let me go."
Sam finds what he think may be a clue – a man called Drew Neely who had killed his family and disappeared three years earlier has been found dead. Sam theorizes that Neely was possessed by a demon, who may have possessed Dean and left Neely's body to die. Sam calls to share the news with Castiel, who is anxious for news of Dean. Picking up that Cas is seriously unwell, Sam backtracks and tells him not to worry, that the clue probably isn't anything.
At a bar called the Black Spur, Dean is singing karaoke – badly – and later has sex with a waitress called Anne Marie. He warns her not to get attached as he's just passing through. Crowley interrupts them, and he and Dean go to play foosball. Later, Dean notices a guy harassing Anne Marie, follows him outside, and delivers a severe beating to him in front of a shocked Anne Marie.
Hannah visits Castiel. She tells him that rebuilding is proceeding in Heaven; Metatron is in jail, and reconciliation amongst the angels is proceeding. However, some angels remain on Earth, and recently two of them – Daniel and Adina – killed an angel who tried to get them to return to Heaven. Hannah asks for Castiel's help in finding them, and he agrees.
In Wisconsin, Sam is investigating Drew Neely's death. When the police show him the security footage from the Gas-n-Sip, Sam recognizes Dean. In the footage Dean is reading a porn magazine when Drew draws a blade and attacks him. Dean fights back and kills him, stabbing him repeatedly with the First Blade. Sam believes that his suspicion that a demon is possessing Dean has been confirmed when Dean's eyes flash black on the tape. He travels to the store himself, where the clerk gives him Neely's phone.
At the Black Spur, one of Abaddon's demonic followers attacks Dean, who fights and kills him.
Sam finds a text on Neely's phone that had alerted the demon to Dean's presence there, and realizes that the demon had also been an Abaddon loyalist. He calls the number, and Crowley answers, revealing that Crowley has been sending Abaddon loyalists after Dean. Sam vows to save Dean or die trying. Crowley taunts him, saying he's jealous that Crowley is Dean's best friend now, and informs him that Dean is not possessed, but that the Mark of Cain has twisted his soul until it is demonic.
Sam traces Crowley's location via an app, a move which Crowley has anticipated. Crowley tells Dean of his talk with Sam and that Sam is coming, to convince him that it is time to leave, as he wants Dean to come with him to Hell and rule alongside him. He explains that he had been sending demons after Dean because he knows that Dean needs to kill to 'feed' the Mark of Cain. He leaves after telling Dean to choose whether to come with him and rule Hell, or not.
During the night Dean drinks and sings karaoke – even worse than before – and drinks a lot more, even shoving a man off the stage when the man tries to usher him away. Later when he's in bed, Anne Marie brings him some water. He proposes that they take off together, but she says that when she saw him beat her ex, she realized he wasn't a good man. Dean is cruel to her, and she leaves, sadly commenting that she knows she is so damaged she'll probably think that she deserved it.
Hannah and Cas travel to find the two rogue angels. Hannah confronts Cas about his fading grace, but he angrily rebuts the implication that another angel die for him to get more grace. They find Daniel and Adina, who want to stay on Earth, having found much there they enjoy. Hannah persists – that they must return to Heaven; Heaven needs rules to operate. A fight ensures during which Castiel has to kill Daniel to save Hannah. Adina escapes. Hannah continues to insist to Castiel that Heaven needs rules, but Cas says that the chaos on Earth can produce good things – art, hope, dreams, love – that Hannah points out are "human things."
On his way to the Black Spur, Sam's car breaks down. A man, Cole, stops to help, but reveals he rigged Sam's car to stop, and kidnaps him. In a barn, he prepares to torture Sam for Dean's location, alluding to some connection to Dean hinted to earlier in the episode, which has lead to him now wanting to kill Dean. He uses Sam's phone to call Dean, who answers as he is driving. Cole demands Dean meet him or he will kill Sam. However, while Dean plans to find and kill Cole one day, he is perfectly willing to let Sam die since he had already told Sam not to come look for him. Dean says that whatever trouble Sam is in now is his own problem. Dean ends the call by hanging up on Cole.
- Sam Winchester
- Dean Winchester
- Cole Trenton
- Anne Marie
- Angel Blade
- Angel Cuffs
- Binding Link
- Busty Asian Beauties
- Castiel's Pimpmobile
- Crossroads Demon
- The First Blade
- Get this
- Goblet of Blood
- Green Cooler
- Mark of Cain
- Men of Letters Bunker
- A Practitioner's Guide to Exorcism
- Sexual Encounters
- Title Card
- Warding Sigils
- "Heartbreaker" by Pat Benatar
- (plays over "The Road So Far" recap of events)
- "I'm Too Sexy" by Right Said Fred
- (the first karaoke song Dean sings)
- "Honey" by Bonjah
- (playing in the bar when Sam calls Crowley)
- "Yes Indeedy" by Ryan Cain and the Ables
- (playing in the bar when Crowley tries to talk Dean into ruling Hell with him)
- "Imaginary Lover" by Atlanta Rhythm Section
- (the second karaoke song Dean sings)