In Kansas City, Missouri a man runs out into an office hallway, running from someone. In a panic he pushes the elevator button while looking behind him. He turns to find a man in a Santa hat in front of him. The man grabs him by the neck, revealing his [[vampire]] fangs. He looks at the mistletoe above him,
feigning going in for a kiss, he twists the mans neck, and disposes of the man's body down the garbage shute in the building. The vampire, Brett, then walks into a room with a woman looking over the city lights, and tells her he killed the last one before he asks her why she chose this building and floor. The woman tells him she likes the view, as her eyes glow blue, revealing herself as [[Michael (Apocalypse World)|Michael]]. Two people enter into the room, led by the [[werewolf]] [[Melanie]] as two new volunteers. As Michael goes down the line of werewolves, he comes across [[Garth]] and recognizes him as a friend of [[Dean Winchester]]. Garth maintains he will be loyal to Michael in order to protect his daughter . In [[the Bunker]], [[Jack]] is eating cereal in the dark alone as [[Castiel]] enters the kitchen and turns on the light. Jack asks Cas not to tell Sam he is eating sugary cereal. Castiel sits in front of Jack and discusses his [[resurrection]], telling Jack it is like a right of passage, as they've all done it. Jack brings up the deal with the [[Cosmic Entity]] and why can't he tell [[Sam]] and Dean. Cas said he could but it would be a burden for them, and he has to be happy when he comes for him, something his life doesn't see a lot of.
Sam is talking on his phone to Garth who telling him how they want him to make the change into one of [[ Michael's Monsters]] , telling him his plan to only pretend to drink the blood / [[ grace]] mixture and spit it out later, before ending his call due to being called by the other werewolf who came with him. Sam and Dean talk about Garth and the situation he is in . Sam says that he brought him out of retirement for this and if any thing happens to him he will feel responsible. Dean reminds him that [[ Naomi]] gave then Michael' s location and they have someone on the inside. He thinks the odds are good. They are soon interrupt by Cas alerts them to Ketch having made contact.
In the library, Jack is sitting at the computer talking to [[Ketch]] on a video call, as Ketch talks about his infiltrating of a compound when Sam asks him if he had the egg. Disappointed they don't care for any pleasantries, Ketch tells the group of how he stole the egg from a Hungarian rare weapons collector, and how on his return from Budapest he was met by a group of mercenaries, forcing him to "drop" the egg, telling them it would arrive in Lebanon in two days. Angry that he sent it in the mail, Ketch explains he improvised, Sam understands but explains that they needed it soon due to planning to attack Michael. At Hitomi Plaza, Garth is nervously waiting on a couch with another werewolf. The other man tells him of his friend who made the change and is immune to silver now. Melanie walks in with two vials of the blood / grace concoction and hands it to the werewolf , who drinks it first She hands a vial to Garth, who hesitates before he drinks it, holding it in his mouth until Michael enters the room forcing Garth to swallow. Michael sits at a desk and talks to Melanie, telling her about a female seen in Omaha, Nebraska. Garth listens from afar and learns Michael is sending someone there to kill her and destroy [[Kaia's Spear|the Spear]]. Dean and Sam search for the packaging facility that will receive the egg they need in Joplin, Missouri. The facility is closed due to it being a holiday, necessitating a break in. Sam receives a call from Garth who tells Sam a recycling plant in Omaha, Nebraska, is where they will find the Spear. Sam asks if he was able to fake them out about making the change, Garth lies and tells him yes as well as telling him of Michael's plan. Sam tells every one what Michael has planned and that Kansas City will become a blood bath, as he plans on turning the whole town on Christmas day. They pair off, Cas and Dean to get the Spear, while Jack and Sam to retrieve the egg. They agree to meet up in Kansas City.
Cas and Dean arrive at the recycling facility Dean tells Cas, and he tells him of his intent to kill Michael for what he did to him. In Joplin, Sam has cut the wires for the security system at the mailing facility. Jack asks if he can pick the lock, telling Sam he learned how on the Internet. Back at the recycling plant, Cas and Dean do not see any of Michael's forces in sight, but realize someone is still close by due to the food still being warm. Jack comes out to the facility with a box. He puts it on top of their car, as Sam notices a black van parked nearby. Sam gets hit from behind, and falls to the ground as Jack is dragged away by two men and put into the van, watching as it drives off. Michael appears in front of Sam with blue glowing eyes, holding the [[Hyperbolic Pulse Generator]] in his hand. Sam get out his [[angel blade]] and charges towards Michael, but is thrown back into a van. The egg melts in Michael's hand dripping to the ground. He again pushes Sam back into the van where he lay unconscious. Garth calls Dean, he can't get Sam on the phone. Dean can't either. Garth asks about the reinforcements, Dean said there were none. The call ends, and Michael appears in the hallway telling Garth they have to talk. Dean and Garth think this has all been a setup. They are soon confronted by Dark Kaia, who agrees to give the Spear if Dean can have Jack open another rift to send her back to her home. She gives him the spear, Dean's phone rings, it is Sam, he tells him what happened. Sam gets into his car and heads to Kansas City.
Two werewolves drag Jack into the room.
Wanting to know why he is there. Michael speaks of how he destroyed Kansas City in his universe, but not without human resistance. He is trying something different this time, using [[monsters]] instead of [[angels]] . An army of monsters. Jack asks why he is telling him all of this. Michael explains how monsters and angels as insects to things like them. He plans to wipe out humanity and seems to think Jack will come around to his way of thinking once his powers come back .
In the parking garage, Brett the vampire sends out the werewolf, telling him to wait on Michael's orders. Brett notices a blue car parked nearby, as he turns, Sam cuts off his head. In a room at the plaza Melanie sees Brett's decapitated body on surveillance footage. She runs and gets on the elevator. Sam is there, he cuts her head off. Jack is still in the room he was taken. Sam is seen peaking in with his machete. He sees Jack, and cuts his ties. They hear footsteps, Garth enters. The three then get off the elevator, Garth is behind them, he is bent over in pain. He is turning. Jack touches his shoulder Garth hits him he tumbles away. Garth is fighting it. Sam grabs him from behind, he gets away and tackles Jack, pinning him to the ground. Garth is sitting on Jack with teeth out and his claws. Then Sam grabs him from behind, Garth says how Michael won't let him stop forcing Sam to choke him out.
Garth is placed the trunk of the [[Impala]] tied up and unconscious. They close the lid and begin to talk of how Michael was spying through Garth. They talk of their strategy of attack, Cas mentions how his presence will be felt by Michael killing any element of surprise. Michael is pouring whiskey in his glass and anxiously sits, waiting for someone. He soon senses Castiel and walks out into the hallway. He quickly finds Cas and beats him to a bloody pulp and drags him into the room, where Sam and Jack are waiting for them. Michael stretches out his arm and fling Jack and Sam to the ground in pain. Dean comes out with the Spear. They fight, but Michael gets the upper hand until Sam slides him the Spear, allowing Dean to cut Michael's arm. As Dean goes after Michael with it, he becomes disoriented and finds it hard to kill him, and begins seeing flashes of himself as Michael. Suddenly, the female vessel Michael had possessed falls to the floor and Dean breaks the Spear in half. Dean turns around to the shock of everyone as his eyes glow blue and has become possessed by Michael once again. He asks why they didn't question why he gave Dean up so soon and explains that Dean was "squirming" too much. He wanted to get back to his family and that Michael was trying to break him, crush him. He said how Dean is not squirming now, he is gone. Michael finishes his drink and says how a whole army is waiting out there for his command and snaps his fingers.
* [[Sam Winchester]]
'''Jack:''' Cas. The deal you made why can't Sam and Dean know?<br>'''Castiel:''' They can.
I-I just don't, I don't want them to. They don't need that burden. You don't need that burden.<br>
'''Jack:''' Of course I do. You did that for me.<br>
'''Castiel:''' You know, the Empty said that it wouldn't come for me until I had finally given myself permission to be happy, but with everything we have going on, with -- with Michael still out there, I don't see that happening anytime soon. This life may be a lot of things, but it's rarely happy.
'''Garth:''' Look, Sam, I knew this was a risky one. Besides, I'll just pull the old fake-swallow and-spit-it-out-later cough syrup trick.<br>
'''Garth:''' Used to work on my Mom. Well, most of the time.
'''Jack:''' My uncle's in the Cage. And you -- you're not family.<br>
'''Michael:''' Well, not literally, no. Our connection, our relation is more a matter of scale of power. Haven't you learned yet? In this reality, monsters, humans, even angels -- they are insects, atoms compared to us. But you -- you're just a child, a mere infant. For you, the past two years -- the entirety of your existence -- feel like eons. You don't even know what time is. But you will. Real time, the time that makes mountains, that wipes out species. You'll see it all with me. Year by year, century by century, and as your power returns and grows, we'll only become more alike. Oh, I know. Your loyalty to Castiel, the Winchesters, the rest of humanity? It will fade. And so will the minor differences -- angel armies versus monster armies, this Kansas City or that Kansas City, one world from another -- they'll fade, too.
'''Sam:''' Walking right into a trap.<br>
'''Castiel:''' Which is set by a full-powered archangel.<br>
'''Michael:''' When I gave up Dean, you didn't think to question it, to ask why? Dean was resisting me. He was too attached to you, to all of you. He wouldn't stop squirming -- to get out, to get back. So I left but not without leaving the door open just a crack.<br>
'''Castiel:''' Why wait?<br>
'''Michael:''' To break him, to crush and disappoint him so completely that, this time, he'll be nice and quiet for a change -- buried. And he is. He's gone. And now I have a whole army out there, waiting, ready for my command
, ready for this.
'''Jack:''' Did you take the decoder ring out of the box?<br>
... The secret password is 'cookie-tacular.'
:''In America, breakfast cereal manufacturers sometimes include toys as part of their marketing to children. A decoder ring usually implements a simple cipher that maps letters to numbers, with a spinning wheel containing the letters and an outer ring containing the numbers (or vice versa). The word or phrase decoded is usually related to the product. In [[Jack]]'s case he is eating "Krunch Cookie Crunch" and the code word is "Cookie-tacular."
'''Werewolf Bro:''' Buddy of mine, he made the change. Says he's immune to silver now. Pretty cool, right? The only thing that can take him down now is the Full Ichabod.
Khttt! Says he's never felt so great. Called archangel grace the ultimate power up . A real Chug Jug... Dude, Fortnite.
:''"Full Ichabod" is a reference to Ichabod Crane from [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Legend_of_Sleepy_Hollow The Legend of Sleepy Hollow], who faced off with the Headless Horseman. [[Sam]] previously compared [[Garth]]'s physical appearance to Ichabod Crane in [[9.12 Sharp Teeth]].''
:''In the online video game [https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/home Fortnite], the [https://fortnite.gamepedia.com/Chug_Jug Chug Jug] is a health item that takes 15 seconds to consume and grants the player full health and full shield.''
Michael snapping his fingers to
signal his army could be seen as a reference to [https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Snapture "the Snapture"] from ''Avengers: Infinity War'', in which the antagonist, Thanos, snapped his fingers, causing half of all living creatures in the universe to be killed.
[https://www.imdb.com/name/nm5437111/ Alex Rose], who played Brett the Vampire, previously played Crowley's Demon in [[8.17 Goodbye Stranger]].