'''Tally, season to date:''' Dean 1; Sam 1; Bobby 1
'''Comments:''' Castiel sends Dean back in time (and space) to Lawrence, Kansas, 1973. There, Dean learns that his dad was a Trekkie, his mom was a hunter, and he was named after his grandmother. Castiel tells him to "stop it," though he is not very clear about what "it" might be. Dean introduces himself to young John Winchester and the Campbells as "Dean Van Halen," and tells the Campbells that he is also a hunter. Samuel Campbell doesn't trust other hunters and refuses to let Dean help him investigate a haunted farm, taking Mary instead. Dean beats them to the farm and soon realizes it's not a haunting - it's the Yellow-Eyed Demon who is making deals left and right, planning to collect in ten years.
'''Tally for season:''' Dean 3; Sam 1; Bobby 1; Samuel 1; Travis 1; Boys 1
The Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester]]==
'''Comments:''' Sam and Dean think they're hunting witches, but it turns out to be a demonic duo bent on bringing Samhain to life. Meanwhile, Uriel and Castiel show up, intending to raze the town in order to stop the seal from being broken. This one also starts off in the middle of a hunt, and it is never declared which brother initiated it. After some discussion, a point in favor of a shared hunt.
'''Tally for season:''' Dean 4; Boys 2; Sam 1; Bobby 1; Samuel 1; Travis 1; Ruby 1
'''Comments:''' Since this is a continuation of "I Know What You Did Last Summer," there is no real hunt for the episode. However, Sam is the one who does the research about Anna and figures out that there's something strange about her family history (and he later finds her grace), which is worth a point.