|Location||Sioux City, Iowa|
|Episode(s)||4.12 Criss Angel Is a Douchebag|
When a few deaths began involving other magicians suffering the same type of death Jay escapes in his magic tricks, Jay was the initial suspect, but he was soon discovered to know nothing about it. When Charlie was supposedly killed the same way, Vernon was the last suspect and Jay accused him of using the cards to kill people. However, Charlie did not die but became younger than before, and revealed that he was the killer and offered eternal youth to Jay and Vernon as well, requiring the deaths of Sam and Dean. Unlike Jay, Vernon wanted to accept the eternal youth. However, Jay used one of Charlie's cards to kill him. Following this, Vernon left Jay, not wanting to speak to him again.