Claire arrive at the home of [{Randy]], and a friend of hers from the group home [[Dustin Tate]]. Randy has gambling debts, and was expecting her to bring him money. He suggests she can help out by robbing the local Gas n Sip.
Sam has found out that Claire was friends with Dustin. He, Dean and Cas confront him as he arrives for his job at Weiner Hut and find out Claire's plan. They intercept her at the Gas n Sip before she can execute the robbery. She is confronts them - angry at Cas for killing her father and at Sam and Dean for letting it happen. She tells them Randy and Dustin are the only family that she hasbefore leaving. The Winchesters and Cas retire to a Tiki Bar. Sam tells Cas not to stew on what Claire said, but that he can't back it better - for some people their father is verything. Cas reflets that he didn't know his "father" and asks Sam and dean whether they lvoed their dad. Sam encourages Dean to tell a story, about a time they were in New York with their dad and Dean snuck out to a club. As Dean tells it, he got very drunk and possibly drugged when John Winchester showed up just at the right time. They both acknowledge that John "wouldn't win any parenting awards" but that he was there for them.