15.08 Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven

Title	Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven
Episode #	Season 15, Episode 8
First aired	December 12, 2019
Directed by	Richard Speight, Jr.
Written by	Eugenie Ross-Leming Brad Buckner
On IMDB	Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven
Outline	A journey to Hell brings the Winchesters and Castiel face to face with the new leadership, and learn that Michael has escaped the Cage.
Monster	God Werewolf Demons
Timeline
Location(s)	Milford, Nebraska Lebanon, Kansas Lewis, Oklahoma Hell
« Previous Episode | Next Episode »

Synopsis

In a casino in Milford, Nebraska, a waitress prepares a drink. She steps over the bodies of her co-workers and patrons to deliver it to Chuck, who is sitting at a slot machine, perpetually winning. When the terrified waitress hands Chuck His drink, He questions if she went easy on the rum, telling her she wouldn't like Him when He's "cranky."

Eileen has gone off hunting by herself, and in the midst of a fight with a werewolf, her gun gets knocked out of her hand; after a brief struggle, she is able to escape and regroup. Drawing her knife, she is about to strike, but she holds back when she sees it is Sam in front of her. At first surprised to see him, she quickly pushes him away before the werewolf can get the jump on him, and kills it. Sam then asks Eileen if he is being overprotective, to which she replies "a little bit."

Back at the Bunker, Sam and Eileen are having a meal when Dean enters the library with a new revelation. He tells Sam and Eileen that he has determined that the demon tablet could defeat Chuck. His theory is that Chuck made the tablets to protect humans in case He was "out of commission," which to Dean shows that Chuck is indeed vulnerable.

Dean sends Castiel to enlist the prophet Donatello to decipher the tablet. Initially refusing Castiel, Donatello eventually acquiesces and is brought to the Bunker, where Sam and Dean explain their plan to lock God away like He did the Darkness. Initially skeptical, Donatello agrees to decipher the tablet, telling the Winchesters that if he goes crazy again, that they should just shoot him. After some time (and a few buckets of fried chicken), Donatello is able to decipher some of Metatron's annotations and personal observations, which reveal that God has a fear, and only told this to His "favorite," who at the time would have been Michael. After learning that Michael is in Hell with Sam and Dean's half-brother Adam, Donatello vents his frustration that nothing the Winchesters do is easy, before suddenly dropping to his seat. Chuck reveals Himself talking through Donatello and warns the Winchesters to drop whatever plans they have or He will go after everyone on their "speed dial," including Jody, Donna, and Eileen.

Sam and Dean determine that the only way to keep their loved ones safe is to go to Hell and get Michael so they can defeat Chuck. They perform a spell and are transported along with Castiel to Hell, where they are immediately set upon by a group of female demons who overpower the three. They suddenly hear a voice command the demons to stop and are shocked to discover that Rowena is now Queen of Hell. She advises the Winchesters that Michael won’t be in the Cage since all the doors were sprung open when Chuck opened the fissure. She orders the demons to find Michael, but they cannot locate him in Hell.

Eileen, who remained at the Bunker to keep the spell's flame burning so Sam, Dean, and Castiel can return, gets a call from another hunter, Sue Barrish, who needs help with a vampire nest. Eileen says she’s busy but will help later if the vamps get closer and she’s available. Meanwhile, at a diner, Adam is enjoying a hamburger while he and Michael discuss their future plans now that that are out of the Cage.

Learning that Michael is now on Earth, Dean places a call to Donatello asking if he has felt any surge in God-like power; he says he hasn't. At the diner, Adam suggests to Michael they find a job, due to having spent whatever money Adam had on him on food. When Lilith appears at the diner, Michael takes over his vessel. Lilith attempts to bring Michael with her to see his father. Michael refuses, telling Lilith if his father wants to talk, He can come to him. When Lilith insists, and grabs onto Michael's arm, the archangel smites her, leaving only a pile of black ash where she sat. Noticing that the entire diner witnessed what he did, Michael snaps his fingers and tells everyone to forget what they saw.

Michael's killing of Lilith causes a surge in power, which Donatello is able to feel and relate to the Winchesters, who are then able to pinpoint him in Cairo, Egypt. Realizing they can't get to him before he moves again, Castiel prays to Michael, and tells him how Chuck is not the father he knew, and asks Michael for help in the coming battle. Michael meets with Castiel, who is able to trap him in a ring of holy fire, which allows for Sam and Dean to restrain him with angel cuffs. At the Bunker, the Winchesters and Castiel explain everything that’s happened to Michael and ask him to help. He is resistant. When Adam’s name comes up in the conversation, Michael hands over control to him to allow Adam to talk with Sam and Dean. Sam and Dean show remorse for abandoning Adam in Hell, but Michael cuts the reunion short and demands to know what they want with him. Upon hearing that they are all just God's puppets, Michael still does not believe the Winchesters and retreats, handing control back to Adam, who tells Sam and Dean to give it a rest.

Adam, however, tries to convince Michael that, even though he hasn't forgiven them for letting him rot in Hell, Sam and Dean try to be on the right side of things. He admits that they even tried to stop him from being Michael's vessel. He reminds Michael that despite everything they know, parents keep secrets. Would it hurt, he asks, to consider what Sam and Dean have told them. Michael tries to explain that it would, because he is God's favorite son and it would be disloyal of him to question his father. In reply, Adam points out that God left him to rot in the Cage as well.

Castiel goes to speak with Michael, who once again refuses to help in their cause. After Castiel provokes Michael into attacking him, he grabs Michael's head and shows him all the things that God has done and how He lied to Michael. While Castiel has been dealing with Michael, the hunter Sue calls Eileen again for help, where Eileen witnesses Sue get attacked on the video call. Eileen then goes to Sam for backup to help Sue. They follow Sue’s directions to an empty parking garage, where they find Sue’s abandoned truck and no vamps to be seen. Sue then walks out from the shadows, causing Eileen to say “Thank God.” Sue morphs into Chuck and replies "Any time" before greeting Sam.

After Michael realizes everything was a lie, and he wasn't the only Michael, he is convinced and agrees to help. He gives them a spell, which will allow them to lock away God like they did the Darkness, but he reveals that the final ingredient they need is the nectar of a Leviathan Blossom to bind all the ingredients together. This flower only grows in Purgatory. With a snap of his fingers, Michael opens a doorway for them, telling Dean and Castiel that it will be open for 12 hours. With the fissure to Purgatory open, Michael prepares to leave. Dean asks to speak with Adam once more and apologizes, telling his brother he didn't deserve what happen to him. Adam simply tells him, "Since when do we get what we deserve?" before wishing Dean and Castiel "good luck" as he walks out of the Bunker.

Characters

• Sam Winchester
• Dean Winchester
• Castiel
• Lilith
• Chuck Shurley / God
• Adam Milligan
• Michael
• Rowena
• Eileen Leahy
• Donatello Redfield
• Sue Barrish

Definitions

• Acting in Unison
• Alcohol
• Angel Blade
• Angel Cuffs
• Angel Lore
• Archangel
• Ass-butt
• Demonology
• Food
• Healing
• Hell
• Hell's Throne Room
• Holy Oil
• Hunters
• Leviathan Blossom
• Lilith's Chamber
• Lucifer's Cage
• Men of Letters Bunker
• Monsters
• Pie
• Portal
• Prayer
• Prophet
• Purgatory
• Rowena's Spellbooks
• Sammy
• Season 15 Callbacks
• Shapeshifting
• Silver
• Smiting
• Spells
• Table of Death
• Tablets
• Teleportation
• Vampires
• Vessel
• Werewolves
• Winchester Family Tree

Music

• "Take Me for What I Am (1971)" by Henry Ford

(playing in the casino that Chuck has taken over)

• "Goin' Straight" by Dick Jr. & the Volunteers

(playing in the diner where Adam and Michael are conversing)

Quotes

Chuck: You went easy on the rum this time, right?

Waitress: Uh-huh.

Chuck: Okay, cool. 'Cause, you know, you don't want me cranky. Keep 'em coming.

Dean: But if Chuck was so freaking invincible, then why wasn't He able to protect us from the dick demons or even the dickier angels? 'Cause, remember, these babies were dictated before He took a powder.
Eileen: So, He was worried about humans, if He couldn't protect them?

Dean: Look, we know that Chuck overpowered His sister, the Darkness, and locked her up. So...
Castiel: We may be able to lock Him up, too.

Rowena: Hello, boys.

Dean: Rowena, we thought you were dead.

Rowena: Oh, I am, dear. Pretty much everyone here is. When I closed the fissure, it did cost me my life, and my soul went to hell. Big surprise.
Castiel: And the demons just... handed you the throne?

Rowena: No one hands you anything, darlin'. I took it.

Dean: Look, man, I didn't want to say anything, okay, cuz I was kind of in a -- in a bad place, and, uh, yeah, I didn't want to jinx it or whatever, but, you know, I tried the family thing, right?

Sam: Yeah, me too. And that's not for us.
Dean: No, not really. But I'm just saying if it was to work, Eileen, you know, she gets it. She gets us. She gets the life. She's hot.
Sam: Dean, I mean, I'm not even --

Dean: Look, all I am saying is you -- you could do worse, okay? And she could certainly do better. Like, so much better. I'm happy for you Sammy.

Castiel: Michael. Michael. This is Castiel. We didn't know each other very well, and our last meeting was... unpleasant. But I know you have been through a terrible ordeal for many years. You've been beyond the reach of Heaven. Been beyond the reach of Earth. Much has changed with both. Heaven is not what it was. And your father -- your father is certainly not who you knew. Michael, there's a battle raging, and you are a warrior, but you must know the nature of this fight. I'm not your enemy anymore. Now we all have the same enemy. God Himself.

Castiel: Michael? Thank you. Thank you for coming. Do you remember me?
Michael: You called me "ass-butt" and set me on fire. And then you helped send me to Hell.

Michael: You're asking me to trust you -- you, who doomed me, you, who let Lucifer walk free while your own brother sat in Hell.

Sam: Doing what we do, we've had to get used to losing people. Probably too used to it. With Adam, we said goodbye because we thought we had to. We were wrong.
Michael: Well, don't tell me. Tell him.
Adam: Hey, Sam. Dean.
Sam: Adam?
Dean: Wait, Mic-- Michael lets you... talk? I mean, he lets you be?

Adam: Uh, yeah. In the Cage, we came to an agreement. We only had each other.

Michael: If my Father is back, He will usher in Paradise.
Dean: No, He won't. Because Paradise is boring and your dad -- He's just looking to be entertained.

Adam: So, I've been thinking. Maybe they're not lying. Hear me out. Sam and Dean try to be on the right side of things. They actually do. They tried to talk me out of taking you on, for example, out of all of this.

Michael: So, you forgive them?
Adam: Oh, hell, no. No. But that's not what this is about. It's -- Look, if they tell you something's off with God, it's because they believe it's true. And if they believe it, it probably is true.
Michael: You and I have been together for years. My Father and I have been together for eternity. I exist because He willed it.
Adam: So He's having a mid-eternity crisis. Or -- Or, maybe you don't know your dad as well as you think you do. The point is, parents keep secrets, right? Does it hurt to ask the question?
Michael: Yes! It would. It would mean that I doubt Him. The Good Son, the Favorite, doubts his Father.

Adam: You still care about that? After He left you in the Cage?

Castiel: You know, Michael, I never really liked you. Even when I was just another angel, I thought you were too haughty, too... to paraphrase a friend, you had an entire oak tree shoved up your ass. But now? I'm looking at you and I... I just pity you. Because you were never God's Favorite. You were just a little part of His story, a tiny part of His story. You weren't even a star. At least Lucifer knew that God can't be trusted. But I guess he was always the smart one. See the truth for yourself.

Michael: God lied to me. I gave everything for Him. I loved Him. Why? I'm not even the only Michael.

Sam: It looks empty.

Sue: Look again.
Eileen: Sue. You're okay. Thank God.

God: Any time. Hi, Sam.

Dean: Before you go... can I talk to him?

Adam: Yeah?
Dean: Adam, I want you to know... we are sorry. What happened to you... You're a good man. You didn't deserve that.

Adam: Since when do we get what we deserve? Good luck.

Trivia & References

The episode title is a play on the first line of the Lord's Prayer which in the traditional Catholic version reads "Our Father, who art in Heaven."

Chuck / Donatello: Oh, Donatello's not here any longer. Hey, guys.

Castiel: It's Chuck.
Chuck / Donatello: Prophets speak the word of God, sometimes indirectly. Sometimes they're My Bluetooth. So, here's the thing. Usually, I really love our little... process. I toss something at you guys, and you slam it right back. It's fun, like tennis. With monsters. But this -- Let this one go.

Bluetooth is a wireless technology, allowing for hands-free communication on mobile phones. Nick had previously compared prophets to old CB radios in 14.17 Game Night.

Rowena: Yes, there are things I miss about being alive. Flesh-on-flesh sex. Amazon doesn't deliver here... yet.

Amazon is a tech company which is primarily an online marketplace. In 2018, its 2-day delivery service had 100 million subscribers globally. Its distribution centers have a reputation for being hellish places to work. In 15.02 Raising Hell, Rowena stated that she had Amazon Prime when talking with Dean about getting the ingredients for her soul catcher.

Rowena: I don't have many regrets, but the few I do still haunt me. Making Napoleon so short was just bitchy. Telling Mick Jagger he had no future when I dumped him. And, well, everything with dear Fergus. Then one day, you die, you go to hell, they make you queen, and... you can't make it right. So fix it!

Napoleon Bonaparte was a French military leader at the turn of the 18th century. He is generally portrayed as short at 5 feet 2 inches (1.57 m), although this was the average height of French men at the time. Mick Jagger is an English singer/songwriter who, despite Rowena's assessment, went on to have a rather successful career as the lead singer of "The Rolling Stones". Fergus refers of course to Rowena's son, generally known by his demon name of Crowley, and their extremely turbulent relationship, for which Rowena has previously expressed remorse in 13.12 Various & Sundry Villains and 13.19 Funeralia.

Michael: Myrrh, cassia, rock rose.

Dean: We've got that.
Michael: And, to bind the spell together, the nectar from a Leviathan blossom.

Each of the ingredients for the spell to trap God are tied to death in some fashion. Myrrh can be seen as a symbol of death when used as embalming oil, cassia can be used to induce abortions in pregnant women, and rock rose can symbolize imminent death. Leviathan blossom gets its name from the Leviathan, the first beasts God created, who nearly devoured the "Petri dish" according to Death, and the flowers grow from the dead bodies of Leviathans.

Minutiae

Filming Locations: Map of known filming locations

Ruth Connell's name appears in the end credits in order to keep her return in the episode a surprise to the viewers. This also marks Ruth Connell's 31st and final appearance as Rowena MacLeod, including her brief cameos in 10.03 Soul Survivor and 10.18 Book of the Damned.

In addition to directing the episode, Richard Speight, Jr.'s band Dick Jr. & the Volunteers provide the track "Goin' Straight" from their debut album The Dance and How to Do It for the episode.

When Sam uses the phrase "Achilles heel", Dean responds as if he is unaware of its meaning (it refers to a person's point of vulnerability). However, Dean has used the term himself at least once himself, most notably in 5.04 The End:

Dean: Long story. The point is... maybe we are each other's Achilles heel. Maybe they'll find a way to use us against each other, I don't know. I just know we're all we've got. More than that. We keep each other human.

Dean also knew what it meant when Sam used the phrase in relation to Veritas in 6.06 You Can't Handle the Truth. Dean uses the phrase himself when arguing with Samuel Campbell about demon deals in 6.10 Caged Heat.

Donatello: Oh. And, guys, when I go crazy again, just shoot me.

Donatello is referencing the last time he read the demon tablet and was corrupted by the dark energies due to being soulless, in 13.14 Good Intentions.

Castiel: Well, I think we're done. It's exactly the spell Rowena used. Just without Rowena.

Castiel is presumably speaking of the spell Rowena used to travel from Hell after Lucifer killed her in 11.10 The Devil in the Details.

Director Richard Speight planned the fight scene in Hell along with stunt coordinator Rob Hayter and fight coordinator Kirk Jacques to showcase the work of the female stunt performers. During the fight, Jensen ad-libbed the line "Are any of us winning?!"

Sam declared that there would be no new King of Hell in 14.01 Stranger in a Strange Land. His declaration technically held, as there was no new king. Instead Rowena became the Queen of Hell.

Rowena's admonishing of Dean and Castiel to fix their friendship is similar to Ellen Harvelle's spirit threatening to kick Dean's ass from beyond the grave if he didn't talk to Sam in 7.07 The Mentalists.

The diner where Adam and Michael meet Lilith is called "Jaci's Red Wagon" after Richard Speight's wife Jaci Hays.

Michael killing Lilith in a flash of white light is reminiscent of Lilith's love for attacking her enemies with blasts of white light, as seen in 3.12 Jus in Bello and 3.16 No Rest for the Wicked. In the former case, she was believed to have killed Nancy Fitzgerald and Victor Henriksen in this manner until Henriksen revealed otherwise during the Rise of the Witnesses in 4.02 Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester.

At the diner, Adam orders a slice of cake that, like often happens to Dean with pie, he never gets to actually finish, due to Lilith's interruption. Michael shoves the cake away after killing the demon, likely because she took a finger of icing.

Michael acting like a petulant child mirrors Lucifer's own petulant reaction in 11.22 We Happy Few after being reunited with God. In Michael's case, he retreated behind Adam so that he didn't have to listen anymore. In Lucifer's case, he hid out in Sam's room to avoid God.

Director Richard Speight, Jr. and Rob Benedict as Chuck on the set of "Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven" -- the first time these friends who have hosted conventions together for a decade have ever worked together on Supernatural.

Sides, Scripts & Transcripts

• 15.08 Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven (transcript)
• Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven Script (Production Draft)
• Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven Script (Blue Pages only)

Promotion

• Promo
• Synopsis & Photos
• Sneak Peek

Interviews

• Jake Abel Previews 'Bad Blood' in Adam's Big 'Supernatural' Return by TVInsider
• Supernatural Boss Previews Dean and Sam's Reunion With Lost Brother Adam — Plus, Michael Returns in Sneak Peek by TVLine
• Supernatural's Rob Benedict on Why Sam and Dean Probably Forgot About Adam by TV Guide
• ‘Supernatural’: Rob Benedict on Chuck and Sam’s Cosmic Connection by Variety
• Supernatural star Rob Benedict says we 'have not seen God go off yet' by EW
• Jake Abel on playing Micahel and Adam by EW