The next morning, Sam is researching Kevin's many aliases online when he gets distracted by thoughts of [[Amelia]] and decides to check up on her electronically. He's looking at a recent credit card application when he hears a rattling noise in the bathroom. He goes to investigate, but it's just a faulty overhead exhaust fan. As he's fixing it, he remembers the days after he met Amelia. He was taking care of the dog he ran over and had decided to stay in town, and the boy at the motel desk, [[Everett]], had hired him on as a handyman at the motel.
Meanwhile, Dean arrives in Eagle Harbor and finds Benny's camper truck. In the back is a cooler full of blood bags. He takes the cooler to the fuel barge that Benny mentioned in his call and finds Benny, weak and bloodied. He helps him, and once Benny's fed and cleaned up, he thanks Dean and makes to leave. Dean isn't letting him go without finding out what happened, though, and Benny realizes that Dean won't be put off. He remembers the way Dean wouldn't give up on rescuing [[Castiel]] from [[Purgatory]], even though the seraph angel attracted monsters like a magnet and was certain that he wouldn't be able to escape through the same rift as them. When he tells Dean that he's going after the vampire who killed him, his maker, Dean is determined to help. They go through Quentin's things and find a logbook with the names of boats, departure times, and destinations. Benny reveals that when he was alive, his vampire nest survived by boarding pleasure boats bound for far-off ports, feeding on the people on board, and then burning all the evidence so that it was lost at sea. Dean immediately coins the term [[Vampirates]], and is shocked that they didn't think of it themselves. Along with the logbook, they find a cable bill with an address on a nearby island. They assume that it's where Benny's maker is also holed up when he's not out at sea, and they head to a closer port in the Impala. On the way, Dean asks what happened with Benny's nest. He tells Dean that their maker was like a god to them, a jealous god who wanted to keep them together and yet separate from the rest of the world. When Benny fell in love with a beautiful Greek woman named [[Andrea Kormos]], he ran away with her and gave up killing humans. He thought they were free from his past, but his maker tracked him down and killed both of them to punish Benny for leaving the nest.
|Characters=