Evan Hudson was one of the four people that had made a deal with a Crossroads Demon at Lloyd's Bar. He had originally made his deal to save his wife, Julie Hudson, who was dying. When his ten years were up, he sent his wife away and prepared to die alone. Sam and Dean arrive as Evan is waiting for death and they convince Evan to let them help him. Sam stays in Evan's home to defend Evan with Goofer Dust, while Dean goes to make a deal with the Crossroads Demon that originally made all of the deals at Lloyds Bar. Dean traps the demon in a Devil's Trap and convinces her to release Evan's soul from the contract in return for Dean releasing her and not exorcising her.
Evan cares for his wife greatly, sacrificing his soul for her health and well-being.
- He is one of the few people to actually survive a deal with a Crossroads Demon and the subsequent pursuit by Hellhounds.
- "No, he's right. I made the deal. Nobody twisted my arm."
- "Julie was dying...So yeah, I made the deal and I'd do it again. I'd have died for her on the spot."