|Location||Lily Dale, New York|
|Episode(s)||7.07 The Mentalists|
Jimmy is a psychic who can read people and has powers of Telekinesis. He runs an emporium and lives at address is 809 1/2 main Street, Lily Dale 14752. His business card reads "Private Readings. No future too grim."
Angry that other, often fake, psychics are successful while he isn't, Jimmy binds the ghost of Margaret Fox to kill them. Sam and Dean meet him while tracking the belongings of Grandma Goldy. Jimmy senses that Sam is dealing with a loss. Later as Dean tries to protect Melanie Golden, Sam returns to find who may have bought items necessary to bind a ghost, and Jimmy misdirects him to a house where a Lamaze class is held.
Realising he's been duped, Sam returns and finds Margaret's skull on an altar and he confronts Jimmy. Jimmy has a gun, but Sam takes it from him, until Jimmy uses his psychic power to take it back. Jimmy reveals that Margret is happy to kill for him, as her abilities were overlooked in her life. Jimmy refuses to let Sam destroy Margaret's bones, and Sam draws his own gun and shoots Jimmy.