Rock, Paper, Scissors
From Super-wiki
Contents
Episodes
2.17 Heart
4.19 Jump the Shark
6.17 My Heart Will Go On
11.13 Love Hurts
While searching the basement of Sonja's hair salon for the qareen heart, Sam and Dean play rock, paper, scissors with the winner getting to search the upstairs. And much to both Sam and Dean's shock, Dean wins by throwing scissors. Happy that he just won, Dean doesn't even care that he still ended up searching the basement.