Talk:Chuck Shirley
09/11/09
Would this page be an appropriate location to put the e-mail address given for Chuck in 4.22? (On the computer screen before Castiel and Dean show up: carveredlund@gmail.com) Or is there another place it would be more appropriate to put it? Or is it already up somewhere and I'm just failing on my search-fu? :-)
Hi, yes, I think that'd be appropriate!!! Wow, I didn't even notice it! Now I totally want to write to him ;-) Lea ndra 19:20, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
I noticed it when I did my reaction post for the ep but couldn't quite read it and some of the commenters filled in the blanks. I've written to it twice so far, nothing coming back yet, but who knows? I'll add it to the page. --CaffieneKitty 19:36, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
Also, is there a page for the in-series Supernatural books? I'm not having any luck finding one. --CaffieneKitty 09:36, 14 November 2009 (UTC)
yes check the Merchandise and Tie-ins categorys. --Missyjack 08:08, 15 November 2009 (UTC)
Hey, stupid question, do we have any confirmation that it's Shurley with a U? Because I have never heard of anyone with the name Shurley-with-a-U, while Shirley-with-an-I is a perfectly sensible name. Much more common as a first name than a last, but it'd be far from the only name that could be either. —EllieMurasaki 14:31, 23 February 2010 (UTC)
- I have checked and its listed as Shurley on imdb and also in the Official magazine, but it seemed strange to me too. --Missyjack 04:14, 24 February 2010 (UTC)
- Know which issue? (Better: got scans?) Because half the S5 episode-airing dates on IMDB, I'm the one put them there, and if the only reason it's Shurley-with-a-U on IMDB is somebody decided to write that schwa as a U instead of an I, I'm not above editing IMDB to fix that... —EllieMurasaki 05:13, 25 February 2010 (UTC)
- Hey, if it's 'Shirley' on the subtitles, why are we not accepting that as canonical? Also, is there a page for the Supernatural books themselves? Because in Ghostfacers ep 4 Maggie says she's read them, or at least she's read Bloody Mary. (This amuses me no end. Though I take it she hasn't read Hell House or Ghostfacers.) And the fact that Maggie's read them really ought to be mentioned on the page for the book series except I can't find the page for the book series. —EllieMurasaki 19:10, 22 April 2010 (UTC)
- Know which issue? (Better: got scans?) Because half the S5 episode-airing dates on IMDB, I'm the one put them there, and if the only reason it's Shurley-with-a-U on IMDB is somebody decided to write that schwa as a U instead of an I, I'm not above editing IMDB to fix that... —EllieMurasaki 05:13, 25 February 2010 (UTC)
I redirected the Chuck Shurley page to a more Canonical page, the page being re-titled under Chuck Shirley. -- GrammarKing, June 20th 2010
I have checked and every other mention i can find fo the character from publciity and media reviews of the Show to imdb, wikipedia, the Official magazine and media appearance by Rob Benedict spells the name "Shurley". I'll weigh that as of greater importance than the spelling on the subtitles at this point. The Season Four Companion Book will be out soon, and we can change the page if that source lists the spelling as different. --Missyjack 04:16, 21 June 2010 (UTC)
